When a Birth Control Implant Goes Wrong

Ask a woman why she chose a birth control implant, and the answer is usually some version of the same thing: she didn’t want to have to think about it. One short appointment, a little numbing, a bandage on the inside of the arm, and years of protection. Nexplanon, the implant used in this country, is a flexible rod about the size of a matchstick, and earlier this year the FDA approved it for up to five years of use.

For most patients, that is the whole story. But I have spent my career representing people hurt by medical care and medical products, and the procedures that worry me most are often the ones everyone considers routine. When an implant goes wrong, it can mean an arm that never stops aching, months of heavy and unpredictable bleeding, a removal that turns into surgery, a pregnancy that should not have happened, or, in rare cases, an implant that is no longer in the arm at all.

I want to walk through how these injuries happen, how to tell whether someone is responsible, and what Virginia law requires before you can bring a claim.

Why Placement Matters

Everything about this device depends on where it sits. The implant belongs just beneath the skin, shallow enough that you can feel it with your fingertips. At that depth it stays clear of the nerves and arteries that run through the inner arm, and it can be removed later through a small incision. Placed deeper, into muscle or the tissue around it, it becomes a different and more dangerous device. The manufacturer’s own prescribing information ties deep insertion to nerve injury, migration, and implants ending up inside a blood vessel. That is why providers must be trained before they insert one, and why the FDA now also requires clinicians to be certified through a federal safety program.

In my experience, implant problems trace back to one of three things: the care the patient received, the implant moving after it was placed, or the device itself. Each points to a different answer about who, if anyone, is responsible.

When the Care Falls Short

Medical malpractice, put simply, is a provider failing to do what a reasonably careful provider would have done, and a patient being hurt as a result. With implants, it tends to look the same from case to case. The implant is placed too deep. A nerve or blood vessel is damaged during insertion, or more often during an attempt to remove an implant that was too deep to begin with; physicians have published reports of ulnar nerve injuries from exactly that kind of in-office removal. No one checks afterward that the implant can be felt, a step that takes seconds. Or a patient comes back saying she can’t find it, and instead of ordering imaging to locate it, someone goes looking with a scalpel.

These are not minor injuries. Nerve damage can mean numbness, burning pain, or a weakened grip that lasts long after the implant is gone. In 2021, a South Carolina woman resolved her case for $600,000 after a Nexplanon placed at a public clinic left her with permanent nerve damage in her arm. Every case turns on its own facts, and no outcome predicts another. But it shows how seriously these injuries are treated once someone examines them closely.

When the Implant Moves

There is also a risk most patients have never been told about: the implant can move. Usually that means a short distance within the arm. In rare cases, the implant enters a vein and travels toward the heart and lungs. European and British regulators added migration to the pulmonary artery to the product’s safety information in 2016, and by 2020 Britain’s medicines regulator reported that the manufacturer had identified 107 cases worldwide of implants reaching the pulmonary artery or chest. The U.S. label now carries a boxed warning about complications from improper insertion and removal, and notes that an implant lodged in a blood vessel may require surgery or a catheter procedure to retrieve.

If you have an implant, a few signs are worth knowing. If you can no longer feel it, or it feels different than it did the week it went in, tell your provider. The same is true of pain, numbness, or tingling in the arm or hand. Chest pain or shortness of breath is different: get seen right away, and call 911 if it is severe. Some women with a migrated implant have no symptoms at all, which is why it is worth checking now and then that yours is still where it belongs.

In a migration case, the central question is usually whether the implant moved on its own or moved because of how it was placed. French health authorities have pointed to deep insertion, sometimes directly into a vessel, as a likely cause, along with trauma to the arm and unusual anatomy. If placement was the problem, the provider who placed it may be responsible. If a patient reported she couldn’t feel the implant and no one ordered imaging, that delay can be a separate failure. Answering these questions takes the insertion records, the imaging, and the opinion of a qualified medical expert.

When the Device Is Not Genuine

The third possibility is one patients almost never consider: that the implant itself was not what it should have been. A device can be counterfeit, a fake made to pass for the real product. It can be a product made for another country’s market and never approved for use here, or one bought from an unlicensed wholesaler outside the regulated supply chain. Or it can simply be expired, even though the label requires insertion before the date on the package. These cases are real. Earlier this year, a California clinic network agreed to pay $750,000 to resolve federal allegations that it bought unapproved or improperly labeled Nexplanon from an unlicensed wholesaler and billed Medicaid for it.

An implant that is not genuine may not release the right dose, may not appear on an X-ray the way the real product does, and was never held to FDA manufacturing standards. The effects are not always as dramatic as an unplanned pregnancy. Many of the women I have heard from went from normal cycles, three to six days a month, to cramping, pain, and heavy bleeding as many as 25 days a month. Irregular bleeding can happen with the genuine product too, so that change alone does not prove anything, but it is a good reason to ask what was actually placed in your arm.

And you do not need symptoms to have been wronged. A woman who was told she was receiving an FDA-approved implant and was given something else has suffered harm in the eyes of the law, even if she never noticed a thing.

If you have reason to question yours, ask the clinic where it purchased the implant and from which distributor, and ask for the lot number and expiration date. Your insertion note should record those details along with the product code. You can also request any notice the clinic sent about your implant and the billing records showing what was charged. If you received an implant in Northern Virginia, read my update on that case here. 

“My Implant Failed and I Got Pregnant. Do I Have a Case?”

This is one of the most common questions people ask about these devices, and it deserves a straight answer: possibly, depending on why it happened. When Nexplanon is placed correctly, fewer than one in 100 users becomes pregnant in a year. That is a strong record, but it is not perfect, and a pregnancy alone does not prove anyone did anything wrong.

What matters is what happened around it. Sometimes the implant was never actually inserted, or was placed so poorly it could not work; the label notes that nearly every correctly placed implant can be felt immediately afterward. Sometimes the timing was wrong, and no one ruled out pregnancy beforehand or explained the need for backup protection. Sometimes the device was expired, counterfeit, or unapproved. Certain medications, including some seizure drugs and herbal supplements, can make the implant less effective, and a provider who prescribes one without a warning may share responsibility. And sometimes a patient told her provider she couldn’t feel her implant, and nobody followed up.

It is also important to understand what a claim like this can and cannot cover. Virginia courts have generally allowed recovery for harms tied to the pregnancy itself, such as medical expenses, lost wages, and complications, but not the cost of raising a healthy child.

What Virginia Law Requires

If any of this sounds familiar, Virginia’s rules deserve your attention sooner rather than later. Most medical malpractice claims must be filed within two years under Virginia Code ยง 8.01-243, and that period usually begins on the date of the care, not the day you realized something was wrong. There are narrow exceptions, such as when a provider concealed the injury, and separate rules apply to children and to wrongful death claims, but they are limited and should not be relied on.

Virginia also does not allow a malpractice case to proceed on suspicion. Before a lawsuit is served, the injured person must already have a signed written opinion from a qualified medical expert stating that the provider fell below the standard of care and that this caused the harm. Identifying the right expert and getting them the records takes time, which is one more reason two years can pass quickly.

Finally, Virginia caps the total recovery against health care providers. The limit depends on when the malpractice occurred: $2.75 million for care between July 1, 2026, and June 30, 2027, increasing $50,000 each year until it reaches $3 million in 2031. Claims against a manufacturer or distributor, such as in a counterfeit or defective device case, can be governed by different rules.

I don’t share any of this to alarm anyone. I share it so that a deadline doesn’t quietly make the decision for you.

Where to Begin

If you believe something went wrong, start with your records. Ask your provider for the insertion note, any removal notes, imaging reports, the implant’s lot number and expiration date, and your billing records. You are entitled to them. Keep a simple log of what you are experiencing: when the pain or numbness began, what makes it worse, whether you can still feel the implant, and every appointment along with what you were told. Photos of bruising or swelling help. And if you have chest pain or trouble breathing, set all of this aside and get medical care first.

If what you have read here sounds like your situation, I’m glad to talk it through with you. The consultation is free, and it commits you to nothing; it simply helps you understand where you stand. You can reach me at 434-404-6062 or here. 

This article is for general information only and is not legal or medical advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.